VyprVPN vs PIA (Private Internet Access): Which is Better?

Private Internet Access (PIA) is among the world’s most famous VPN services. It’s often pitted against VyprVPN, which is a rising star in the industry. 

Experts almost unanimously agree that the latter is better in almost every regard.

Comparison

Below is a comparative table showing all the specifications of each VPN:

logo vyprvpnlogo pia vpn
Logging Policy No LoggingNo Logging
Jurisdiction Switzerland United States (Five-Eyes Member)
EncryptionAES-256
SHA-256 Hash Authentication
AES-256
AES-128
SHA-256 Hash Authentication
4096-bit RSA Key Exchange
Protocols OpenVPN UDP
OpenVPN TCP
IPSec/IKEv2
IPSec/L2TP
PPTP
WireGuard
Chameleon
OpenVPN UDP
OpenVPN TCP
IPSec/L2TP
WireGuard
Ad and Malware BlockersYesYes
Kill SwitchYes (Windows & macOS)Yes
Leak TestsNo Leaks FoundNo Leaks Found
Speed TestsFastFast
Torrenting & P2PYes (Optimized P2P Servers)Yes (On all servers)
StreamingNetflix
Amazon Prime
BBC iPlayer
Firestick
Roku (Via Router)
Kodi
Apple TV (Via Router)
Android TV
Netflix
Amazon Prime
Hulu
Firestick
Kodi
GamingWindows
Android
iOS
Xbox One (Via Router)
PS4 (Via Router)
Nintendo Switch (Via Router)
Windows
Android
iOS
Xbox One (Via Router)
PS4 (Via Router)
Nintendo Switch (Via Router)
CompatibilityWindows
macOS
Android
iOS
Tor
Selected Routers
Windows
macOS
Linux
Android
iOS
Chrome
Firefox
Opera
Tor
Selected Routers
Simultaneous Connections510
Servers700+3300+
ChinaYesSometimes (1 Out of 3 Servers Worked)
Split TunnelingYesYes
Additional FeaturesVyprVPN DNS
VyprVPN Cloud
PIA MACE
Prices$12.95/Month
$3.75/Month (1 Year)
$2.50/Month (2 Years)

Special offer: 80% discount for a 2-year subscription;
71% discount for a 1-year subscription
$9.95/Month
$3.33/Month (1 Year)
$2.69/Month (2 Years)

Special Offer: 73% off and 2 months free for a 2-year subscription
Our Rating4.44.3
Websitewww.vyprvpn.comwww.privateinternetaccess.com

The two services have many things in common. At the same time, lots of stuff differentiate them from one another.

Privacy & Security

VyprVPN’s headquarters is in Switzerland while Private Internet Access is in the US. Only the former service isn’t governed by the Five Eyes Alliance. 

The latter needs to follow restrictive copyright and privacy laws that leave it handicapped. If anything, this puts it at a great disadvantage versus its competitor.

Encryption Comparison

Like all popular VPN clients, Private Internet Access and VyprVPN adhere to robust encryption standards. Both make use of AES 256-bit encryption as well as SHA-256 hash authentication.

The handshake that VyprVPN employs hasn’t been disclosed. Meanwhile, it’s known that PIA utilizes RSA-4096, which is standard in the industry.

VPN Protocols

Both services support OpenVPN (UDP & TCP), IPSec (IKEv2 LT2P), and WireGuard. What sets them apart is that VyprVPN also lets subscribers use PPTP. In addition, it has its own proprietary protocol that’s based on OpenVPN called Chameleon.

Leak Protection

Private Internet Access and VyprVPN proudly say they provide 100% protection against leaks. To determine if this is true, I ran some tests using IPLeak.net. Before we take a look at the results, here’s how things fared without me using any VPN:

IP Leak Test – No VPN

(IP Leak Test – No VPN)

Next, this is how Private Internet Access and its server in Singapore did:

IP Leak Test – PIA Singapore

(IP Leak Test – PIA Singapore)

Last of all, here’s the results after I moved to VyprVPN’s server in the same location:

IP Leak Test – VyprVPN Singapore

(IP Leak Test – VyprVPN Singapore)

Fortunately, neither VPN disappointed me. Both were able to keep me anonymous without any hiccups. Therefore, they’ve proven their trustworthiness. When using both, I can rest assured that troublemakers won’t be able to find out my location.

Server Security

Sad to say, none of the two have transitioned to a RAM-based network. Hence, the only thing stopping each from disclosing your private information are their no-logging policies

A good thing is that both services haven’t been recorded to ever give up data to the authorities.

In Conclusion

Between the two, I’d have to say that VyprVPN has better security. That’s because it supports more protocols and is based in Switzerland. In the country, it remains free to operate without interference from the government. Thus, it's the winner of this VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access round.

Speed Test

Private Internet Access isn’t known for being speedy. In comparison, VyprVPN has a reputation for being one of the fastest services on the market. Some have even gone as far as to compare it with NordVPN and ExpressVPN, which are the most renowned clients in the industry.

I had to know which service has better speed capabilities so I tested each one out. Here’s a screenshot of my base connection for reference:

Speed Test – No VPN

Speed Test – No VPN

Now, this is how PIA’s Singapore server changed it: 

Speed Test – PIA Singapore

Speed Test – PIA Singapore

Here’s how VyprVPN’s same location server did:

Speed Test – VyprVPN Singapore

Speed Test – VyprVPN Singapore

It was surprising to see the two perform quite similarly. Still, VyprVPN did slightly better than its competitor. As a result, it’s the winner of this category.

Torrenting & P2P

VyprVPN doesn’t have a fully enabled P2P network while PIA does. To compensate for this, it detects torrenting activity then automatically connects you to the right  server. From a convenience standpoint, this is great for all users.

I had to know if Private Internet Access and VyprVPN could protect me whenever I partake in a torrenting session. Due to that, I conducted tests using IPLeak.net once more. Here are my results without any VPN being employed:

Torrenting Leak Test – No VPN

Torrenting Leak Test – No VPN

And here’s how PIA’s and its Singapore server did:

Torrenting Leak Test – PIA VPN Singapore

Torrenting Leak Test – PIA VPN Singapore

Finally, here’s how VyprVPN and its corresponding server did:

Torrenting Leak Test – VyprVPN Singapore

Torrenting Leak Test – VyprVPN Singapore

To my surprise, VyprVPN didn’t pass my test. My IP address was detected while I was torrenting with it. Because of that, the winner of this PIA vs VyprVPN round is Private Internet Access by default.

Streaming

Many people have complained about PIA’s subpar streaming capabilities. It only unlocks a couple of libraries on Netflix. Furthermore, it’s not capable of bypassing the blocks of other platforms such as Hulu, BBC iPlayer, and Amazon Prime.

On the other side of the spectrum is VyprVPN. Reports have universally stated that it can work around the geoblocks of Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime, BBC iPlayer, and other streaming websites without any hiccups.

Netflix

Netflix is without doubt the most popular streaming platform. For that reason, I had to know if each VPN could function alongside it. The first service I tried was Private Internet Access. My title of choice was Spotlight. Here’s the result:

Netflix US – PIA VPN

Netflix US – PIA VPN

Here’s how VyprVPN’s server in New York did when I tried to watch the same movie:

Netflix US – VyprVPN

Netflix US – VyprVPN

As you can see, both VPNs were able to stream the title. Be that as it may, the winner for this category is VyprVPN. How come? Because it can unlock more services and it’s less prone to giving you problems with quality and buffering since it’s faster.

Gaming

I’m a competitive Call of Duty Mobile player who must have a VPN that could safeguard me whenever I partake in a gaming session. To see if either could meet my needs, I played a few matches while connected to each one.

My experience with Private Internet Access was decent. While there were several instances of lagging and drops in frames, I was able to finish my matches without hiccups. Also, it only took a couple of seconds to get into the game.

VyprVPN’s performance was stellar. Not once did the service give me problems with frame drops or lagging. Thus, I have no choice to declare it as the winner of this category.

Compatibility

Private Internet Access and VyprVPN’s creators have made both compatible with lots of platforms. For a better understanding of the matter, please refer to the table below:

VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
Windows
macOS
Android
iOS
Tor
Selected Routers
Windows
macOS
Android
iOS
Linux
Chrome
Firefox
Opera
Tor
Selected routers

The lack of a Linux app and browser extensions make VyprVPN shorthanded. It drastically falls short versus Private Internet Access, which functions on all mainstream platforms with the exception of Chromebook OS.

Simultaneous Connections

VyprVPN allows for a maximum of 5 simultaneous device connections. Meanwhile, PIA gives you the chance to up to 10 devices using one account. Hence, it’s the clear winner in this round of our match between the two VPNs.

Servers

Because it’s quite new, VyprVPN doesn’t have a large network. It operates a mere 700+ servers across the globe. As such, it fails to offer much in regards to connectivity. Furthermore, it’s not that good with maintaining user anonymity on paper.

Private Internet Access has been around for a few years already. Thus, it boasts a rather large network of 3300+ servers. For that reason, it’s the winner in this Private Internet Access vs VyprVPN round of our battle.

China

China’s draconian internet censorship measures are a huge obstacle for any VPN. Luckily, the majority of users have reported that it makes short work of the Great Firewall.

You can’t say the same for Private Internet Access. Expert reports and posts on Reddit all say that it’s not the best service to have in China. While it can sometimes leap across the country’s censorship measures, it cannot do the job consistently.

Interface & Usability

Private Internet Access and VyprVPN’s native apps are remarkably similar. They all take on a minimalistic approach to things. When using them, you shall discover that their interfaces are extremely easy to get around. On top of that, they’re also highly configurable.

PIA VPN Interface

PIA VPN Interface

Upon opening PIA’s app for Windows 10, you’ll instantly notice the quick connect button. Under that is a tab where servers can be selected. To toggle the settings menu, simply click on the dot icon found on the upper right corner.

VyprVPN Interface

VyprVPN Interface

VyprVPN’s corresponding app has a lighter theme. On its home scream, everything you need is on display. And yes, this includes the settings menu. Thanks to that, using it is elementary and can be done by just about anyone.

Since the apps of VyprVPN are simpler to utilize and more aesthetically pleasing, the service is the winner of this category.

Additional Features

Unfortunately, you won’t be getting an extensive set of features upon buying a Private Internet Access subscription. The only thing the service has is PIA MACE, which is the service’s own proprietary ad and malware blocker.

In comparison, VyprVPN has two additional features that you can take advantage of. The first one is VyprVPN Cloud. It’s a cloud storage solution for people that utilize VirtualBox, Amazon Web Services, and DigitalOcean. Second is VyprVPN DNS. With it, you can further protect yourself from DNS leaks.

Since it has more one-off features, the winner of this category is VyprVPN. 

Customer Support

Look at the table below to see what each VPN offers when it comes to customer service:

VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
Live ChatYesYes
Email SupportYesYes
Phone SupportNoNo
Ticket SupportYesYes
Video Tutorials NoYes
Online Knowledge BaseYesYes
Average Response Time4 Hours45 Minutes

Private Internet Access and VyprVPN offer the same things when it comes to customer support. That said, what sets them apart is their average response time. 

After contacting PIA, you can expect a reply within just 45 minutes. Meanwhile, it takes 4 hours for a representative of VyprVPN to get back to you.

Prices

To get a full grasp of how each VPN prices themselves, look at the table:

VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
Subscription Lengths1 Month ($12.95/Month)$9.95/Month
1 Year ($3.75/Month)1 Year ($3.33/Month)
2 Years ($2.50/Month)2 Years ($2.69/Month)
Highest Price Per Month$12.95$9.95
Lowest Price Per Month$2.50$2.69
One Year Price$45 (18 Months)$39.95
Money-Back Guarantee 30 Days30 Days
Special Offer80% discount for a 2-year subscription
71% discount for a 1-year subscription
73% discount for a 2-year plan + 2 months free

Private Internet Access is way cheaper than its competitor. For just $39.96, you’ll be able to get a 1-year subscription. In the VPN industry, this is awesome as few services can compare. As such, it's the winner in this VyprVPN vs PIA round.

Verdict

Is VyprVPN better than Private Internet Access?

Yes. VyprVPN is an awesome VPN that’s almost superior in every way to PIA. With it, you will be getting better security, faster connection speeds, superior unblocking capabilities, simpler apps, and connectivity in China.

With all that said, Private Internet Access is still a wonderful VPN. It’s perfect for those who want to get a great VPN at a decent price.

About the author 

Kris Soliongco

Kris has two passions in life: writing and tech. He’s been building computers since he was eight years old and is very knowledgeable about online security. The first time he was exposed to VPNs was in 2016. Since then, he’s used a plethora of services and has gained much experience.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
>